Really, The
Avalanche could have been a great ‘leftovers’ album.
Shorn of some of the fat, with a different release
structure for a couple of (the same) tracks,
Sufjan Stevens could have continued to wow all
and sundry. Instead, this Illinois seconds
album is very much an odds ‘n sods release.
For starters, none of the versions
of “Chicago” – acoustic,
adult contemporary easy listening, and Multiple Personality
Disorder versions – should have been combined with
the original Illinois version to be a single,
rather than have appeared here. Additionally, several
of the meandering instrumentals towards the end of The
Avalanche could most certainly have been left
aside.
But, for the most part, it is a
lovely collection of songs once more, with Sufjans’ overly orchestral
style on show once more. The likes of “Mr. Supercomputer” are
excellent, but the simple fact of the matter is that
this song is not too far removed from the joy of
the quaisi-title track of Illinois. Likewise, “The
Mistress Witch From McClure” is similar in many ways
to “Casimir Pulaski Day”.
If one thing is certain, it’s that
many elements of The Avalanche deserved
to be heard – Sufjan
Stevens is the sort of songwriter capable of achieving
the remarkable seemingly on a whim, and of pretty
much doing as he pleases. “Adlai Stevenson” is just
a joyous slice of melodies and pop genius, and the
world is better for it having seen release. So despite
its inconsistencies, The Avalanche is a highly
enjoyable diversion away from Stevens’ commitment
to releasing an album for every American State, and
a clever accompaniment to the superior Illinois.