This is sound
of DJ Danger Mouse getting his just dues. After
creating the Grey Album,
and following it up by being the producer of Gorillaz
(which, no matter who is involved, is always going
to seen as a Damon Albarn project), Gnarls Barkley
is when Danger Mouse comes into his own.
It helps that “Crazy” is a single
of utter brilliance. Cee-Lo’s vocals are the finishing
touch on a warm base of soul. Of course, the problem
with St. Elsewhere appearing after such
an unbelievable slice of warm sound is that the
rest of it doesn’t quite match the heights of that
song, which manages to encompass soul, pop, and
a Beatles-like melody all in one.
It’s strange that “Gone Daddy Gone” by
the Violent Femmes is covered as well – and that
it’s done in such a copycat manner. You’d expect
Danger Mouse to mess with the rhythm, but instead
he plays it straight. Far better is “Smiley Faces”,
another instant pop confection, while “The Boogie
Monster” has really great production. “Who Cares?” is
another clear album highlight.
The biggest problem with St.
Elsewhere is that it’s not as varied as you
might necessarily come to expect. But perhaps
there was sense in that decision too – having
Cee-Lo as the voice throughout the album means
that it has a consistency more appropriate to
a pop release than a hip-hop one. For, make no
mistake, St. Elsewhere is very much a
pop-focussed release, akin to Moby’s Play.
Expect it to be just as popular and as inescapable
as that release too.