A strange release,
more often than not Sound of Superman features
a bevy of covers by unknown bands, rather than
the originals we’re all familiar with.
For instance, a band called Nightmare
of You cover the Flaming Lips’ deliriously wonderful “Waitin’ For
the Superman”. Why not go with the original, which
is a pearler? Similarly, Ray Davies’ “(Wish I Could
Fly Like) Superman” is handled by a group called
the Sun. The album itself opens with emo-poppers
the Academy Is butchering RE.M.’s “Superman”.
Now while the idea of giving over
great originals to be interpreted by a bunch of
nobodies is fine,
in practice it’s another story. Put simply, these
covers don’t resonate in the same way as the originals – what
Dave Grohl thinks of Paramore’s take on “My Hero” is
anyone’s guess, but you can bet it wouldn’t be complementary.