Underoath
want you to think they’re skull-crushingly heavy – that
theirs is the sort of music predestined to be blared
out of disaffected teen bedrooms and agitate nervous
parents. It’s not. It’s the same trick the Used
pulled with their self-titled debut; the pop hooks
found on Underoath’s third album Define the
Great Line give it away.
Oh, it’s certainly furious – guttural
screaming is combined with sing-song patterns.
It’s for this
reason that the band have leaped onto the major labels,
as underneath the aggressive intent are some genuinely
strong songs that offer more than standard screamo
fare. Opener “In Regards to Myself” is certainly
more clichéd than most, but the strength of Define
the Great Line is its depth.
Coming from the Xtian music scene
of Florida, the band still show their roots occasionally – “Salmanir” and “There
Could Be Nothing After This” explore theological
ideas. What’s best about Define the Great Line is
that the likes of the stripped-back and spoken-word “Salmanir” explore
interesting production textures and different sounds
to the band’s normal fare, showcasing just how far
they’ve come since they debuted some four years ago.
Underoath aren’t there yet, but Define
the Great Line gets them closer to where
they need to go. The epic “Casting Such a Thin
Shadow” shows
just how good the band can be when they level their
sound at and use it to their advantage, combining
both power and panache. While Define the Great
Line is a good record, Underoath are capable
of being great.